Skip to the content

Compare Your AMICA Homeowners and Auto Insurance Renewals with an Independent Insurance Agent in New England (Massachusetts, New Hampshire, Connecticut, Maine, and Rhode Island)

Amica Mutual Insurance is a local New England insurance company headquartered in Lincoln, RI. Many don’t know that Amica is actually the oldest mutual insurer of automobiles in the United States.

At Premier Shield Insurance, we see the value in having ‘mutual insurance’ companies.

We offer auto and home rates through Progressive, Safeco, Plymouth Rock, and Metlife Insurance who are AMICA mutual insurance company alternatives.

Many of our insurance carriers offer immediate accident forgiveness while with AMICA you need to earn points through Platinum Choice. With Good Driving Rewards coverage you’ll earn Advantage Points that lower or eliminate costs if you’re in an accident.

Compare AMICA Insurance Quote Homeowners & Auto MA & CT

AMICA Insurance offers very competitive prices for both homeowners and auto insurance, no question.

If you do have AMICA and you are searching for a lower price for auto or homeowners insurance, we can help you.

Premier Shield Insurance partners with top national, local and regional insurance companies to find you more affordable insurance in MA and CT.

Residents of Connecticut and Massachusetts save money by calling 774-847-7746 and compare AMICA insurance quotes for auto and homeowners.

About Amica Mutual Insurance Company

About AMICA Mutual Insurance

AMICA Mutual Insurance Company
Customer Service Phone Number
: 1-888-702-6422
Headquarters: 10 Amica Center Boulevard. Lincoln RI 02865-1167
Founded: 1907
Website: AMICA Mutual Insurance Company
Chairman & CEO: Robert A. DiMuccio
Estimated Annual Revenue: $100 Million
Employees: 3,684
SIC Codes: Industry: Industry: 6331—Fire, Marine, and Casualty Insurance, Industry: 6411—Insurance Agents, Brokers, and Service, 
Parent organization: Amica Mutual Group
Social Media

Top AMICA Competitors or Alternatives in MA & CT

Arbella Insurance | Concord Group Insurance | GEICO MA | Hanover | Liberty Mutual | COMMERCE | Metlife | Plymouth Rock | Progressive Insurance | Quincy Mutual | Safeco Insurance | SafetyTravelersVermont Mutual

News for Amica and Amica’s Competitors

Amica Insurance Reviews 2020

  • 4.3 Stars 702 Reviews Amica Insurance Reviews 2019 – Clearsurance
  • 2.5 Stars 126 Reviews Yelp
  • 4 Stars 51 Reviews Amica Insurance Reviews | Insurance Agency – WalletHub
  • 1.5 stars 68 Reviews Consumer Affairs
  • 2.5 Stars 11 reviews Google Reviews
  • Amica Mutual Insurance Company Review – The Balance
  • Nerdwallet
  • 2 Stars 4 REviews Is Amica Life Insurance As Good As People Say? [Verified Reviews] – BEST COMPANY
  • 1 star 3 Reviews Amica Auto Insurance Reviews – Is it a Scam or Legit? – HighYa


  • Highly-rated by J.D. Powers & Associates and A+ Rating by A.M. Best
  • Consistently receives customer service awards year after year
  • Customer praise in the areas of customer service and the speed in paying claims
  • Variety of customer payment options available


  • Low-ranking consumer reviews on trusted sites like Google & Yelp
  • Some customer complaints about the handling of claims
  • Reports of AMICA increasing in premium without an explanation
  • Lack of local offices or relationship with an insurance agent.

Top New England AMICA Competitors for Homeowners and Auto Insurance Prices

Arbella | Bunker Hill InsuranceConcord Group Insurance | GEICO | Hanover Insurance | Liberty Mutual Insurance | MAPFRE | Metlife | Plymouth Rock | Progressive Insurance | Quincy Mutual | Safeco Insurance | Safety Insurance | Travelers Insurance | Vermont Mutual

Question Consumers, Homeowners, and Policyholders Have About AMICA

  1. Is Amica A good auto insurance company?.
  2. Is Amica better than Geico?
  3. Is America cheaper than geico?
  4. Who is the best insurance company for home and auto?
  5. Does Amica Insurance have local agents?
  6. Does Amica offer accident forgiveness?
  7. Is Amica Insurance Expensive?
  8. Does my Amica car insurance cover rental cars?
  9. Does Amica have roadside assistance?
  10. Does Amica have a way to compare other insurance companies quotes, prices and rates?
    No. Premier Shield Insurance will be able to help you and your family compare prices, rates, and coverage, while helping you save time and money. Start by calling 774-847-7746 to request a quote for home and auto insurance

Related Insurance Pages: New England Agnecy for Home Insurance, AMICA Auto Insurance Renewal Comparison, Insurance Agency